Senate Democrats pick the leader of their new majority by secret ballot on Dec. 1, and Chuck Schumer's camp says Sen. Chris Van Hollen's challenge is really about killing the filibuster. Van Hollen does want it gone. The Congressional Record shows Schumer led the last attempt to break it in 2022, and at least 24 senators his allies now count as supporters voted with him.
When is the vote, and how does it work?
The closed-door leadership election is scheduled for Dec. 1, Politico reported Monday night. The voters are the 55 or 56 Democratic senators set to be sworn in early next year, which means newly elected members get a ballot before they ever take the oath. A winner needs a simple majority of the caucus: 28 votes, or 29 if Democrats take Alaska's still uncalled seat.
Schumer allies floated moving the vote up to this month, which would take a caucus vote to change the schedule, The Hill reported. Senators who spoke to Politico showed little appetite for that. "I would oppose expediting before we've had a full process," said Sen. Jon Ossoff of Georgia. Van Hollen opposes any change. The caucus does not post its internal rules publicly, so these details come from senators and reporters, not a published rulebook.
Who has the votes right now?
Van Hollen announced on Nov. 12, writing on X that "Americans called on us to unrig an economy rigged against working people" and "To deliver, we need new leadership," according to FOX 5 DC. Schumer answered within hours: "I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader." The Associated Press called it the first contested race for the top Senate Democratic job in decades, and reported that Sen. Bernie Sanders and Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed back Van Hollen, while Sen.-elect Sherrod Brown, Sen. Angus King and Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto back Schumer (AP via WWBT).
Van Hollen had four public commitments as of Friday, The Hill reported, and Schumer's allies predict more than 40 votes. Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin said she is "not voting for Sen. Schumer" but has not endorsed anyone. On ABC's "This Week," Van Hollen said Schumer's team is "trying to instill fear in people who may say that they're gonna support me," per The National Desk. King's reply to the whole fight, quoted by The National News Desk: "Why would you fire the manager when you just won the World Series?"
Is the filibuster what this race is really about?
Schumer's side says so. A Schumer confidant told The Hill that progressives want "Medicare for All" and an end to the filibuster, and an insider called the challenge "counterproductive." Van Hollen has not hidden his view. At a Denver event on Nov. 13 he said, "We need democracy in the United States Senate, and that means allowing, ultimately, a majority of senators" to decide, according to Fox News. "My personal view has been all along that the filibuster is an antidemocratic provision," he added, per Just the News.
Here is the part the Schumer camp leaves out. On the night of Jan. 19, 2022, Schumer himself tried to change the rule so a voting bill could pass with 50 votes. He called it "a very simple, limited proposal" that "only applies to the voting rights bill before us today." It failed 52 to 48 when Democratic Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema joined all 50 Republicans, according to the Senate's official roll call.
Official record
Congressional Record, Senate, Jan. 19, 2022, page S347: Rollcall Vote No. 10 on Schumer's appeal of the chair's ruling during debate on H.R. 5746, the Freedom to Vote: John R. Lewis Act. Every Democrat who voted nay was voting to overrule the chair and change how the filibuster applied to the bill.
"On this vote, the yeas are 52, the nays are 48. The decision of the Chair stands as the judgment of the Senate." Congressional Record, Jan. 19, 2022, S347
Read or download the full 71-page Senate proceedings for that day (PDF) or view it on GovInfo.
Van Hollen and Schumer are both on the nay list. So are 24 senators who appear on the list of Schumer supporters a Schumer ally gave The Hill, including Kirsten Gillibrand, Mark Kelly, Tim Kaine, Cory Booker, Brian Schatz, Patty Murray, Mark Warner and Sherrod Brown. The 2022 version was narrower than Van Hollen's call for a 51-vote Senate. It still shows that most of this caucus has already voted once to get around the 60-vote bar.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune, who voted to keep the filibuster in 2022 and has refused to scrap it since. Official portrait by the U.S. Senate Photographic Studio via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
Republicans have had the chance to do the same thing and passed. President Trump posted "Get rid of the Filibuster, and get rid of it, NOW!" on Truth Social last year, and a spokesman for Majority Leader John Thune answered that "Leader Thune's position on the importance of the legislative filibuster is unchanged," according to the Washington Examiner. That rule now protects the Republican minority from a 55-seat Democratic majority.
How far left is the push behind Van Hollen?
Van Hollen's own record gives the answer. In January he posted on his official Senate site that he will "NOT support any funding for Trump's ICE's operations" (Sen. Van Hollen). AP reported he has criticized Schumer's ties to Israel and to special interests, though he has not yet laid out a full agenda.
The incoming senators lining up against Schumer lean further. Minnesota Sen.-elect Peggy Flanagan said Democrats need "a progressive champion" to lead, and Illinois Sen.-elect Juliana Stratton said, "I've already said that I will not support Chuck Schumer as leader in the Senate," according to Newsweek.
Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who told Fox News a Van Hollen win would be a red line. Official U.S. Senate portrait via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
At least one Democrat says the shift would cost the party a seat. Sen. John Fetterman told Fox News host Kayleigh McEnany "it would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen." Asked whether that would be a red line for staying in the party, he answered, "Yeah, absolutely," Newsweek reported.
What should Republicans watch on Dec. 1?
The secret ballot means no senator has to own a vote for Van Hollen in public, and the margin will leak anyway. A strong showing from a challenger who wants a 51-vote Senate tells you how much pressure a Majority Leader Schumer will face on the rule, even if he keeps the job. Democrats are five seats short of 60, or four if they win Alaska. The filibuster is the reason that gap still matters, and the 2022 roll call shows how many of them have already tried to close it.
Top photos: Sen. Chuck Schumer (left) and Sen. Chris Van Hollen (right), official portraits by the U.S. Senate Photographic Studio via Wikimedia Commons (Schumer, Van Hollen), public domain.