Secure Payments

Free Shipping

Hassle-free Returns

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Fifth Circuit Says the Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, and DOJ Conceded It. The Louisiana Dealer Serving 97 Months Hasn't Won Yet

Fifth Circuit Says the Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, and DOJ Conceded It. The Louisiana Dealer Serving 97 Months Hasn't Won Yet

A federal appeals court ruled Thursday that the Second Amendment's plain text covers the sale of firearms, and the Justice Department conceded the point at oral argument. The Fifth Circuit's Nov. 19 ruling in United States v. Deare sends a Louisiana gun-shop owner's challenge to the federal dealer-licensing law back to the trial court, but it does not throw out his conviction or his 97-month prison sentence.

What did the Fifth Circuit actually decide?

The court's unsigned opinion is short and blunt. "The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms," the panel wrote in No. 24-30241, quoting its own 2025 ruling that "the right to 'keep and bear arms' surely implies the right to purchase them." It then added a line gun owners will want to remember: "During oral argument, the government conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms."

On that basis, Judges James Ho and Andrew Oldham vacated the district court's order refusing to dismiss the indictment and remanded the case "for further proceedings." Judge Catharina Haynes dissented.

The lower court had gone the other way. In 2023 it called 18 U.S.C. 922(a)(1) "a modest regulation of the commercial activity of selling/transferring firearms" and said the licensing and record-keeping rules "affect only the seller," so the Second Amendment was not even in play. That reasoning is now off the table in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.

Official record

United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, filed Nov. 19, 2026. Page 2, which contains the court's holding, is shown below.

"The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms." Per curiam opinion, United States v. Deare, Nov. 19, 2026
Page 2 of the Fifth Circuit's Nov. 19, 2026 opinion in United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, holding that the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms

Read or download the full 12-page opinion with concurrences and dissent (PDF) or view it on the Fifth Circuit's website.

Who is Jeremiah Deare?

Deare owned Dave's Gunshop in Lafayette, Louisiana, and was the responsible person on its federal firearms license. According to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Louisiana, prosecutors said he and his wife, Sarah Fogle, sold or tried to sell hundreds of guns from their home and at gun shows without the background checks and records the law requires. Agents seized 246 firearms from the house, and the indictment sought forfeiture of 619.

The case is not a sympathetic one in every respect. When the couple was sentenced in April 2024, ATF said some of the sales went to people legally barred from owning guns, and that the pair kept going after an ATF warning conference in September 2019. Deare got 97 months. Fogle got 60.

Shoppers browsing long tables of handguns for sale at the Houston Gun Show in the George R. Brown Convention Center

Handguns for sale at a gun show in Houston, inside the Fifth Circuit. This is not a photo of Deare's business. Photo by M and R Photography (Flickr user glasgows) via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY 2.0.

Why does a ruling for a convicted dealer matter to ordinary gun owners?

Because the principle does not belong to Deare. If buying and selling guns sits inside the Second Amendment's text, then every federal rule on who may sell, and how, has to survive the history test from Bruen. The government can no longer win just by calling a law "commercial regulation."

Judge Ho's concurrence went straight at that dodge. "It seems obvious that constitutional rights are meaningless if the Government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens are able to exercise those rights," he wrote. To Haynes's point that the amendment "doesn't mention sellers," he answered: "By that logic, the First Amendment doesn't mention sellers, so presumably booksellers aren't covered by the First Amendment, either. But that can't be right."

James C. Ho testifying at his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing, seated behind a name placard

James C. Ho at his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing. President Trump appointed him to the Fifth Circuit in 2018. Image from U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee video via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

What did Judge Oldham tell the trial court to do?

Oldham, joined by Ho, wrote that restricting sales "obviously 'infringe[s]'" the right, both for the seller, whose property right includes the right to dispose of a gun, and for the buyer, "because the right to keep an item always includes the right to acquire it." He told the district court to follow the Fifth Circuit's 2026 decision in Elite Precision Customs v. ATF, which he said "enjoined enforcement of certain provisions of 18 U.S.C. 922(a)."

He also took aim at DOJ's fallback. In a supplemental brief, the government argued that a 2025 suppressor case, United States v. Peterson, makes 922(a) "presumptively constitutional." Oldham said Peterson "was gravely mistaken and should be overruled at the earliest opportunity," and that stretching it from registration to sales would move "from football to baseball to ballroom dance." His summary of DOJ's theory: "This is wrong coming and going and coming back again."

Andrew S. Oldham at his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing, seated behind a name placard

Andrew S. Oldham at his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing. President Trump appointed him to the Fifth Circuit in 2018. Image from U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee video via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

Is the federal dealer-licensing law dead?

No, and nobody should read Thursday's ruling that way. The panel decided only step one of the Bruen test, that the conduct is covered. Whether licensing and record-keeping for people "engaged in the business" fit the nation's historical tradition is now the trial judge's job. Haynes said she would have affirmed outright because Deare never showed the rules were "abusive."

Even some gun-rights scholars see limits. Law professor Eugene Volokh, writing at The Volokh Conspiracy, said he is "skeptical of the argument that the Second Amendment secures a right of sellers independent of the right of buyers." That split, buyer's right or seller's right, could decide how much room Washington keeps to regulate dealers.

What is settled in the Fifth Circuit is the starting line. The government's own lawyers admitted in open court that selling guns is constitutionally protected activity, and the court wrote it down. The Reese ruling already protected buyers under 21. Now sellers have a foothold too, and every challenge to a sales rule in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi starts from there.

Top photo: The John Minor Wisdom U.S. Court of Appeals Building in New Orleans, home of the Fifth Circuit, at night in November 2024. Photo by Daniel Hartwig via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY 2.0.

Previous post
Next post