A Biden-appointed federal judge in San Francisco ruled Thursday that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins likely broke the Establishment Clause with her Christmas and Easter emails to USDA staff. Headlines said the judge ordered her to stop religious messaging. The operative order does something odder: it tells a Cabinet secretary to obey her own department's religious-expression memo, five days before she would normally send a Thanksgiving note.
What did the headlines say the judge did?
"Judge orders Rollins to stop religious messaging in USDA emails," Agweek reported. The Deseret News went with "Judge halts Brooke Rollins' Christian messages to USDA staff." Politico's story ran under a web address reading "federal court blocks ag secretary's Christian emails."
The ruling is real and it is a loss for Rollins. U.S. District Judge Trina L. Thompson, whom President Biden put on the bench in 2022 according to the Federal Judicial Center, granted a preliminary injunction in National Federation of Federal Employees v. USDA, No. 3:26-cv-04406. But the paragraph that actually binds the secretary never uses the words "stop," "Christian" or "Jesus."
What does the order actually say?
The court "ORDERS that the Secretary must recognize certain boundaries when disseminating messages which convey religious content." Those boundaries are lifted word for word from USDA Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019, the November 2025 guidance on religious expression that Rollins' own department issued. She "must stop if a colleague asks" her to stop, "cannot create a hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome advances," and "cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates."
The same order lists what she may still do. She may "discuss" her beliefs "with interested colleagues," "share why" her faith "is meaningful," "politely invite coworkers to religious services or events" and "express religious viewpoints during appropriate conversations." Thompson wrote twice that she "expresses no view whatsoever on what the Secretary can and cannot do in her personal capacity."
Official record
Order Granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction, National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 3:26-cv-04406-TLT (N.D. Cal.), ECF 59, filed Nov. 19, 2026. Page 20, with the operative order, is shown below.
"Instead, this Court requires the Secretary to observe her own directives. USDA Secretary's Memorandum 1078-019. The April 5, 2026, and December 23, 2025, messages go too far." Judge Trina L. Thompson, Nov. 19, 2026
Read or download the full 21-page order (PDF) or view it on CourtListener.
Which emails crossed the line, and which did not?
The complaint, filed May 13 by the union and six USDA employees, walked through four all-staff messages. On July 4, 2025, Rollins closed with "May God continue to protect the United States of America." Her Nov. 26, 2025 Thanksgiving email credited the first Thanksgiving in part to "gratitude towards a loving God."
Thompson singled out only the other two. The Dec. 23, 2025 Christmas video called Jesus "our Savior" who "came to free us from our sins." The April 5, 2026 Easter email opened "He is Risen indeed!" and compared USDA employees to "the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room." The judge held that the "we," "us" and "our" in those messages assumed every recipient shared the secretary's faith.
Brooke Rollins arrives at USDA headquarters in Washington on her first day as Secretary of Agriculture, Feb. 13, 2025. U.S. Department of Agriculture photo via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
How did a holiday email become "coercion"?
After Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, the 2022 case that cleared a high school coach to pray at midfield, courts judge Establishment Clause claims by history and tradition, with coercion as the key marker. Thompson found coercion in three things: Rollins' rank, her use of an official account to reach roughly 100,000 employees, and what she called the "alienating language" of the two emails.
She leaned hard on the inbox. Employees are "expected to read" the secretary's emails, the order says, because past ones covered relocations, the Deferred Resignation Program and shutdown plans. One plaintiff said she was told it was "not possible" to be taken off the list. Thompson also quoted Rollins from a filed declaration exhibit: "I have been sued a couple of times for, they say, talking about Jesus too much, but I'll never stop talking about Jesus."
The Justice Department's August brief argued the opposite. "The Constitution does not mandate secularism in government affairs," it opened. The emails "do not request, much less coerce, anyone to do anything," DOJ wrote. Thompson's own order concedes the messages did not single out dissenters or tie anyone's job to a reaction.
The Phillip Burton Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in San Francisco, home of the Northern District of California's San Francisco division. Photo by Marincyclist via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Why does it reach all 100,000 employees?
The Supreme Court's 2025 ruling in Trump v. CASA limited judges to relief "necessary to provide complete relief to each plaintiff." Thompson acknowledged that and then cited CASA's own loud-music example to justify covering everyone. Because USDA offers no opt-out, she wrote, she "must enjoin the dissemination of such emails" to non-parties too. A suit brought by six employees and one union now governs what a Cabinet secretary may send her entire department.
She also dismissed the union's Administrative Procedure Act claims, finding the emails are not final agency action. Only the constitutional claim survives.
What happens on Thanksgiving?
Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26. Last year's message credited "a loving God," and the court did not list it among the messages that "go too far." Whether a similar note this year counts as "pressure" under a standard borrowed from an HR memo is a question the order leaves to Rollins and her lawyers.
A USDA spokesperson told the Associated Press the ruling is "a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary," as quoted by Reason, and the department is weighing an appeal to the Ninth Circuit. Thompson set a case management conference for Dec. 17. Until then, a secretary who says she will "never stop talking about Jesus" has a federal judge looking over her outbox.
Top photo: Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins speaks beside President Donald Trump at a White House event on the Make America Healthy Again Commission, May 22, 2025. Official White House photo via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).